Head to Head
| Modus Super Series Week 6 | 2023/12/13 13:05 | Scott Mitchell v John Henderson | 1-4 |
| Players Championship 5 2020 | 2020/02/22 14:10 | John Henderson v Scott Mitchell | 3-5 |
Home History
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/27 21:00 | Scott Mitchell v Sebastian Bialecki | 3-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/27 20:15 | Adam Lipscombe v Scott Mitchell | 1-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/27 18:45 | Scott Mitchell v Thomas Lovely | 4-3 |
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/24 12:05 | Marvin van Velzen v Scott Mitchell | 2-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/24 11:05 | Scott Mitchell v Doug Boehm | 4-1 |
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/24 10:20 | Ray Mulvey v Scott Mitchell | 1-4 |
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/24 09:45 | Scott Mitchell v Kevin Painter | 4-1 |
| Modus Super Series Week 9 | 2024/04/24 09:10 | Sebastian Bialecki v Scott Mitchell | 4-1 |
Away History
| World Seniors Champion of Champions 2024 | 2024/03/23 15:20 | John Henderson v Andy Hamilton | 8-10 |
| Players Championship 6 | 2024/03/19 14:10 | Michael van Gerwen v John Henderson | 6-3 |
| Players Championship 6 | 2024/03/19 13:10 | Callum Goffin v John Henderson | 1-6 |
| Players Championship 5 | 2024/03/18 14:30 | Lukas Wenig v John Henderson | 2-6 |
| UK Open 2024 | 2024/03/01 15:15 | Gian van Veen v John Henderson | 6-3 |
| UK Open 2024 | 2024/03/01 14:00 | Dom Taylor v John Henderson | 5-6 |
| UK Open 2024 | 2024/03/01 12:05 | Kevin Burness v John Henderson | 4-6 |
| World Seniors Darts Championship 2024 | 2024/02/18 21:05 | John Henderson v Colin McGarry | 5-0 |