Head to Head
| Iceland Cup | 2024/02/14 19:30 | Valur v UMF Selfoss | W | 36-26 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2024/02/01 19:30 | Valur v UMF Selfoss | W | 38-21 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2023/09/22 19:30 | UMF Selfoss v Valur | W | 19-32 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2023/03/17 19:30 | UMF Selfoss v Valur | L | 33-31 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2022/11/07 19:30 | Valur v UMF Selfoss | W | 38-33 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2022/05/08 19:30 | Valur v UMF Selfoss | W | 36-27 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2022/05/05 19:30 | UMF Selfoss v Valur | W | 29-35 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2022/05/02 19:30 | Valur v UMF Selfoss | W | 36-25 |
Home History
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/05/02 19:30 | Valur v UMF Afturelding | W | 33-29 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/04/28 19:30 | UMF Afturelding v Valur | L | 29-26 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/04/25 19:30 | Valur v UMF Afturelding | W | 30-29 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/04/22 19:30 | UMF Afturelding v Valur | L | 31-23 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/04/17 19:30 | Valur v UMF Afturelding | W | 35-33 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/04/08 19:30 | UMF Stjarnan v Valur | W | 28-32 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/04/05 16:30 | Valur v UMF Stjarnan | W | 30-21 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2025/03/26 19:30 | Valur v Haukar Hafnafjordur | L | 33-35 |
Away History
| Iceland Cup | 2024/12/09 19:30 | UMF Selfoss v FH Hafnafjordur | L | 25-35 |
| Iceland Cup | 2024/11/01 20:00 | Ih Hafnarfjordur v UMF Selfoss | W | 33-38 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2024/04/05 19:30 | UMF Selfoss v IF Grotta | L | 32-33 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2024/04/02 19:30 | Haukar Hafnafjordur v UMF Selfoss | L | 33-24 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2024/03/27 19:30 | UMF Selfoss v IBV Vestmannaeyjar | L | 20-29 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2024/03/22 19:30 | UMF Stjarnan v UMF Selfoss | L | 24-19 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2024/03/01 19:30 | UMF Selfoss v HK Kopavogs | W | 26-22 |
| Iceland Úrvalsdeild | 2024/02/22 19:30 | Fram Reykjavik v UMF Selfoss | L | 28-24 |